Fall on Cape Cod is a magical season—crisp mornings, cozy afternoons, and plenty of reasons to slow down and savor life’s simple pleasures. And what better way to embrace the season than with a perfectly brewed cup of coffee? The Cape is full of unique cafés, bakeries, and coffee houses where you can sip, relax, and soak in the local flavor.
Here are some of our favorite spots to check out during your stay at The Old Harbor Inn.
1. Three Fins Coffee Roasters – Chatham
Tucked into one of the most unique spaces on Cape Cod—an old swimming pool—Three Fins is unlike any coffee shop you’ve visited before. Just steps from the Cape Cod Rail Trail, it’s a perfect stop for bikers and walkers looking for a mid-ride pick-me-up. Not only do they serve excellent cappuccinos, but they also operate as a chocolate factory. Be sure to catch a chocolate-making demonstration while sipping your latte “in the pool.”
2. Pain d’Avignon Boulangerie – Chatham
This French-inspired café is a local favorite for both lunch and coffee. Known for their rich cappuccinos and homemade pastries, Pain d’Avignon offers the perfect European-style escape right here in Chatham. Pair your coffee with their legendary French Onion Soup or treat yourself to a flaky croissant—it’s the ultimate comfort food experience on a crisp fall day.
One of the newest additions to the Chatham coffee scene, Hey Joe & Jam is as creative as it is delicious. With a jam-centric theme, this coffee house weaves homemade jams into its drinks and baked goods. The atmosphere is lively, with music from local artists and a vibe that invites you to sip, snack, and even dance a little. Don’t miss this truly unique stop.
4. Snowy Owl Coffee Roasters – Chatham, Brewster & Sandwich
With several locations across the Cape, including one right on Main Street in Chatham, Snowy Owl is a must-visit. Known for their freshly roasted beans and creative specialty drinks, they’ll give you the perfect boost before a day of shopping downtown. Whether you prefer a pour-over, cold brew, or seasonal latte, their baristas make every cup with care.
With two convenient locations, Chatham Perk is the go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. It’s a welcoming space to grab your morning latte, a quick pastry, or even a casual lunch. The friendly atmosphere makes it an easy favorite during your stay.
6. Lighthouse Keeper’s Pantry – Yarmouth
What started as Kelly’s childhood hobby of selling homemade jams has become a Cape Cod viral sensation. Today, the Lighthouse Keeper’s Pantry is famous for its Fluffy Seagull Latte—a decadent mix of marshmallow fluff and peanut butter syrup inspired by the classic New England fluffernutter sandwich. Be prepared for a line; this social media favorite is worth the wait.
7. Great Awakening Coffee House – Hyannis
If you’re a fan of seasonal flavors, this is your spot. Known for their Pumpkin Spice Latte and creative menu of specialty drinks, Great Awakening is all about coffee as art. Try the Lavender Latte, Strawberry Rose Latte, or Apple Pie Latte for something truly unique—and utterly Instagram-worthy.
8. Hot Chocolate Sparrow – Orleans
A Cape Cod classic, Hot Chocolate Sparrow is beloved for its frozen coffee drinks, homemade chocolates, and fudge. It’s a perfect stop if you’re exploring the Outer Cape, and the menu has something to please everyone in the family.
9. Nirvana Coffee Company – Barnstable
Nirvana Coffee is the quintessential small-town coffee house. Cozy, welcoming, and always bustling, it’s a great spot to relax with a latte or cappuccino while people-watching in historic Barnstable Village.
10. PB Boulangerie Bistro – Wellfleet
Transport yourself to France at this authentic boulangerie in Wellfleet. Known for its artisan breads, buttery croissants, and perfectly balanced espresso drinks, PB Boulangerie is a must-stop for coffee lovers with a taste for European flair.
Sip Your Way Through the Cape This Fall
From cozy neighborhood cafés to unique specialty drinks, Cape Cod has no shortage of coffee shops to explore. Whether you’re savoring a cappuccino in Chatham, trying the viral Fluffy Seagull Latte in Yarmouth, or indulging in a chocolate croissant in Wellfleet, each stop brings its own local flavor and charm.
When you stay at The Old Harbor Inn, you’re just steps away from some of the best coffee spots in Chatham—and only a short drive from countless more across the Cape. This fall, warm up with a cup of coffee and discover why our local cafés are just as unforgettable as the views.